The Argument Against Women s Combat - 1122 Words

Debunking the Arguments Against Women in Combat There are many who would argue that allowing women, who are physically unprepared, to fight in combat would affect the cohesiveness and combat readiness of the units in which they serve. Government officials and military personnel are a just a few of the leaders behind this opposing argument. When asked about women in ground combat, President Bush summed up his position in four words, â€Å"No women in combat† (Curl and Scarborough A01). He supported his statement further by claiming that, â€Å"The policies currently in place that prevent women from fighting in combat have served our nation well. There is no reason to change what is already working. Our military is successful and will continue to be so† (ibid.). In saying this, however, he is providing an emotional fallacy to the listener. He is appealing with Americans to keep with their traditions. Bush also, unintentionally, gives a post hoc fallacy when he alludes to the fact that if women fought in combat, our military wouldn’t be as successful. Furthermore, he makes the assumption that if women were allowed to fight in combat, they would negatively affect unit cohesion and male bonding, but he gives no evidence to support his assumption. Other opponents argue that women aren’t really interested in fighting in combat, they’re more concerned with the benefits they would get as a result. Anna Simmons, a Professor of Defense Analysis at a Naval Postgraduate School, stated this,Show MoreRelatedWomen s Fight For Combat Roles1267 Words   |  6 Pages Joan of Arc: A women in Combat A great leader knows how and what to do in any given situation. Great leaders know how to adapt, and find a way to conquer a specific task or obstacle. There has been an ongoing debate about whether women should have access to combat roles. Many argue that women are not physically build to match the strength of a man. A young lady by the name of â€Å"Joan of Arc† or commonly known as â€Å"The Maid of Orleans† was a young leader of the 15th century who changed the course ofRead MoreWomen Should Be Integrated Into Combat Positions1057 Words   |  5 PagesWomen should be integrated into combat positions such as infantry, artillery, and Special Forces. If a woman chooses this kind of challenge, then she is more than capable. Women are as tough as men. They can do what a man can do, and if that is going into combat then yes, why not? Women can fight, shoot, run, work hard, and win for this country like the men of this country do. Women have been in combat for a long time , but now women are actually in combat rather than helping the men out with injuriesRead MoreThe Secretary Of Defense And The Chairman Of The Joint Chiefs Of Staff1441 Words   |  6 Pagesrescission of the 1994 Direct Ground Combat Definition and Assignment Rule (DGCDAR). The DGCDAR restricted assignments of women to communities or jobs within the military in or collocated with direct ground combat units below the brigade level, in long-range reconnaissance and special operations forces, and in positions involving physically demanding tasks. This now correlates to the opening of previously closed occupations, to include the USMC infantry, to women who can meet occupation-specific,Read MoreWomen During The United States Military1345 Words   |  6 Pages 9 April 2016 TOULMIN ESSAY Women have always served in the United States Military, since the beginning of the existence of the United States. I will make the argument, that women can and should be allowed to serve in combat roles, that are traditionally open for men only. Combat does not distinguish between the sexes. This is an important issue for everyone. The main reason, why women have never been allowed to be in combat roles, is because the sight of a wounded woman on the battle fieldRead MoreThe Female Combat Pilots Of The Soviet Union s Air Force During World War II Essay1664 Words   |  7 PagesIn her book on the female combat pilots of the Soviet Union s air force in World War II, former US Air Force intelligence officer turned historian Reina Pennington meets the war on the eastern front at an intersection of women s history, military history, and Soviet social history. Wings, Women, and War is the first scholarly survey of this topic, and it covers these units formation, training, performan ce, and post-war demobilization. The book s foreword author, eastern front historian JohnRead MoreSexual Assault And Sexual Harassment1322 Words   |  6 PagesWomen in combat is a sensitive topic throughout the Armed Forces. Although in January 2013 the Military made the decision to end the ban on women in combat, many still oppose this decision. Many Combat jobs have very strict requirements, such as physical abilities. There are many concerns of women being able to fulfill these types of requirements. Another big concern is the risk of sexual assault and sexual harassment, many people feel that women in combat jobs are at a higher risk of being subjectedRead MoreWhy Women Should Be Drafted and Serve in the U.S. Military during War1291 Words   |  6 PagesSection #15654 April 22, 2013 Why Women Should be Drafted and Serve in the U.S. Military during Time of War Throughout time women have gone to war along-side their male counterparts without any question as to what role they couldn’t play but rather what contributions they brought with them. History shows that women have played a vital role in military combat and have been very successful filling any role that their male equivalent has played during combat. Military women have led armies into battle,Read MoreThe Issue Of Abortion And Abortion Essay1567 Words   |  7 Pages The issue of abortion is a controversial one; there are arguments on both sides of the debate. In 1973 the national case of Roe v. Wade, sparked political decisions that created a national right to abortion. Further, Roe v. Wade declared that unborn children are not `persons nor are they entitled to the same constitutional protection as `born children (Baird, Rosenbaum, 2001). However, Roe v. Wade did not end the debate, nor, did it stop both sides for continuing the fight for their individualRead MoreDylan Madden. Dr. Brian Henderson. English 201. 16 March1713 Words   |  7 Pagesmanufacturing processes, but lately we wonder whether or not if it’s safe to put our faith in the hands of cold machinery. Today, robots have been known to provide care for our children and the perhaps even the elderly. They even provide service to our men in combat. However, it doesn’t change the fact that there are those who feel uncomfortable with machinery. It might be child’s p lay when talking about how robots will one day rule over humans whether people see that kind action from movies such as The TerminatorRead MoreA Number Of Aristocratic Class Women And Men Opposed Suffrage Rights958 Words   |  4 Pages A number of aristocrat-class women and men opposed suffrage rights for female in order to protect their own economic standings. Individuals from this particular social class were owners or high ranking officials of industrial corporations and textile factories in the urbanized northeastern region of US. They faced economic losses because the labor unions would push for local to state reforms by taking striking actions to mend any mistreatment that they experienced. Thus, this aristocrat-class